Menu

Horned Frog Foodies: Katie Becker’s Tasty Good Toffee

Using her grandmother’s milk chocolate and pecan-topped toffee recipe, an alumna started a sweet business.

Photograph of TCU alumna Katie Becker seated on a grassy lawn, smiling at the camera while wearing a white-and-blue plaid shirt and blue jeans.

From holiday batches shared with coworkers to sellouts at local craft shows, TCU alumna Katie Becker followed each small surge of enthusiasm to what became Tasty Good Toffee. Courtesy of Laura Matoush Photography

Horned Frog Foodies: Katie Becker’s Tasty Good Toffee

Using her grandmother’s milk chocolate and pecan-topped toffee recipe, an alumna started a sweet business.

In this new series, TCU Magazine visits with alumni in the food and beverage industry. Send recommendations to tcumagazine@tcu.edu.

Katie Becker ’02, founder of Tasty Good Toffee in Lincoln, Nebraska, built her business from a beloved family recipe. Shortly after graduating from TCU, she learned how to make toffee from her grandmother, who was happy that Becker wanted to keep their family tradition alive. For a decade, Becker made toffee for the holidays and other special occasions, sharing it with family, friends and coworkers. Their growing enthusiasm pushed her to start selling toffee at craft shows, where she repeatedly sold out. Becker officially launched Tasty Good Toffee in late 2013; today, she offers multiple flavors and ships nationwide. Visit tastygoodtoffee.com. 

What is most important in the process of making toffee?

It is really good butter, pure cane sugar and a couple of other secret ingredients, and you just boil it within an inch of its life. Its just good basic ingredients and patience and trying not to burn yourself. Im always so honored when people spend their hard-earned money to buy it, and even more impressed when they believe in it enough that they want to give it to somebody they love.

What are some of your favorite flavor combinations?

The most popular are Grandmas original Milk Chocolate Pecan Toffee and then my personal favorite, Dark Chocolate Sea Salt. We have White Chocolate Pecan; we found out that lovers of Harry Potter feel it tastes like the butterbeer you buy at Universal Studios Harry Potter World, so that has a secret little fan base. Churro is a very popular flavor. We have some spicy toffees with ghost pepper dust, and that really came from a joke with a co-worker who grows his own hot peppers, dehydrates them, grinds them up and puts his pepper dust on everything.

What strategies have been most effective in growing your customer base?

I do a lot of in-person events, and I give out samples. It’s really fun on my side of the toffee table to see people take a sample and then watch their face light up in joy and recognition. Lots of people will say it reminds them of their own grandma at Christmastime. It’s fun to see people get excited once it hits their taste buds thats what fuels me to keep going.  

Photograph showing three varieties of toffee arranged side by side on a dark blue-purple background.

Katie Becker’s toffee flavors include her grandmother’s original milk chocolate pecan and her personal favorite, dark chocolate sea salt. Courtesy of Christy Waybright Photography

How did your advertising degree from TCU impact your career path?

I did spend time working in advertising agencies and marketing firms and in-house agencies. And when I look back, all of the experiences I had from TCU the classes I took, the internships, the study abroad in London every step led me here. I take a little of everything I learned in what I do as a business owner. Always continue learning, always continue networking because you never know what steps might lead you to something you never knew was on your path.

What advice do you have for somebody who has a dream of starting their own business?

If it’s something that youre passionate about, if you cant stop thinking about it and if youre excited to wake up in the morning and get started on it, then you know youre onto something. Ive tried a couple of other things that definitely werent a fit. Toffee is still the thing if I have to miss a major commitment or wake up at 4 a.m. to make toffee or drive eight hours to an event to do toffee Im still really excited about the overall process of it.

Editor’s Note: The questions and answers have been edited for length and clarity.